It is one of the grander ironies of modern travel that a Western tourist can step off a bullet train in Shenzhen, pay for a flat white using an app on their phone, stroll past an Apple Store, and conclude: “Well, clearly the Communists threw in the towel.”

It is an understandable mistake. We tend to picture Communism through a distinctly 1980s lens—long queues for grey bread, drab concrete tower blocks, and men in oversized hats reviewing missile parades. Because modern China looks less like a Soviet breadline and more like a sci-fi set, many assume the ideologues have retired to run boutique coffee shops.

They haven’t.

In official circles, the current arrangement is known as the “primary stage of socialism”. Translated into plain English, the theory goes like this: building a utopian society is terribly expensive, and free markets are exceptionally good at generating cash.

Deng Xiaoping neatly captured this pragmatism with his famous maxim: “It doesn’t matter whether a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice.” The market cat caught the mice, wealth accumulated, and infrastructure bloomed.

However—and it is a rather large “however”—the Party keeps its hand firmly on the steering wheel.

While everyday entrepreneurs can sell bubble tea or design apps, the state retains absolute ownership over the “commanding heights” of the economy: energy, banking, telecommunications, and heavy industry. Even in private tech giants, the Party isn’t merely an interested observer; it sits in the boardroom, maintains internal committees, and gently reminds executives who is actually in charge.

Consider Jack Ma. The charismatic co-founder of Alibaba was the undisputed poster boy of Chinese private enterprise. Yet the moment he publicly criticized state regulators, his corporate empire was promptly reined in, his lucrative IPO halted, and he effectively vanished from public view for months. It was a stark reminder that under a socialist market economy, private wealth is a temporary privilege granted by the state, never an absolute right.

Historians and political analysts often note a troubling historical parallel here: 1930s Germany. The National Socialist regime similarly allowed private industrialists to keep their titles, factories, and profits—provided their production served the totalitarian goals of the state. The danger of this economic hybrid is that it grants an authoritarian one-party state the raw power, innovation, and tax base of private capitalism without any of the constitutional checks, balances, or individual freedoms of a liberal democracy.

To a true believer in the original doctrine, none of this is a betrayal of the plan. It is the plan. You use market incentives to build a world-class economy first; only then do you complete the grand socialist vision.

So the next time someone points to Shanghai’s skyline as proof that capitalism won, it might be worth remembering: the red flag flying over the city isn’t just there for decoration.