Jacob Rees-Mogg has recently taken to YouTube to inform us that the English are a “mongrel” people—a haphazard patchwork quilt of whoever happened to hop off a boat with a sword or a trade agreement. While meant as a worldly dismissal of biological purity myths, it relies on a premise that is, frankly, dreadful science.

If having ancient ancestral inputs makes a population a “mongrel” people, then every ethnic group on Earth is a mongrel group. The Han Chinese, continental Europeans, and even the Māori—whose distinct ethnogenesis in New Zealand took shape around 1300 AD—are all products of ancient population mergers. Yet no one rushes to declare their ethnic identity a fiction.

The actual genetic reality of England, as modern ancient-DNA studies show, is one of remarkable stability. The English ancestral recipe was largely locked into place by the early Middle Ages (around 700–900 AD), consisting of a Bronze Age Bell Beaker substrate (~45%), Iron Age continental flow (~25%), and early medieval Anglo-Saxon migration (~30%). That gene pool coalesced in place for over 1,300 years—so much so that official census records show that as late as 1961, over ~98.5% of the population carried this exact long-standing ancestral lineage.

What confuses commentators is that genetics and culture rarely move in lockstep. The Roman invaders gave us baths and urban administration but left virtually zero long-term genetic imprint. The Normans swapped out the kings and introduced French legal terms, yet left no demographic dent. Conversely, while native Briton DNA survived in the majority (~60%+ of our underlying ancestry), their Celtic language and culture were utterly swallowed by Old English due to the social prestige of incoming Saxon settlements.

This brings us to the modern double standard. In an eager push for inclusion, well-meaning commentators insist that “anyone living in England is English.” But this flattens crucial distinctions. Moving to a country doesn’t instantly confer an identity, just as being born and raised here bestows a vital civic Englishness (sharing in our culture, law, and public life) without altering one’s family tree. Insisting that “English” means mere residency or cultural adoption effectively erases ethnic Englishness—a real, traceable ancestral lineage tied to this island for over a millennium.

We can comfortably embrace civic hospitality without pretending the historical English ethnicity vanished into thin air.